Olivia's Cafe

Disney's Old Key West Resort

Dinner Menu
September 2024

  • Appetizers

  • Crab Cake
    Pan-seared and served with Jalapeño Aïoli, Grilled Pineapple Salsa, and Chayote Slaw

    $15 
  • Seasonal Market Salad
    Mixed Greens, Quinoa, Avocado, Edamame, Orange, and Key Lime Vinaigrette

    $12 
  • Savory Hushpuppies
    Served with Key Lime Mustard

    $12 
  • Beer-braised Mussels
    Local Florida Ale, Jalapeño, and Grilled Crostini

    $18 
  • Shrimp Cocktail
    Jumbo Shrimp, Key West Cocktail Sauce, Tropical Slaw, and Citrus

    $16 
  • Homemade Soup of the Day
    Made fresh daily

    $10 
  • Entrées

  • Slow-cooked Prime Rib*
    Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes and Broccolini

    $36 
  • Mojo-brined Pork
    Butter-poached Potatoes, Savory Purée, and Mustard Gastrique

    $29 
  • Mahi Mahi*
    Mahi Mahi with Fingerling Potatoes, Corn Succotash, Chorizo, Citrus Butter, and Corn Silk

    $30 
  • Shrimp Scampi
    Jumbo Shrimp, Linguine, Tomato, Scallions, and Citrus Butter Sauce

    $29 
  • West Indian Tofu and Coconut Curry
    Mango-Coconut Curry, Crisp Vegetables, Jasmine Rice, and Cilantro

    $23 
  • Signature Bacon Cheeseburger*
    Cheddar, Crispy Onions, Avocado, and Bacon Jam with House-made Key West Ketchup and Aïoli

    $24 
  • Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken
    Mashed Potatoes, Southern Gravy, Biscuit, and Seasonal Vegetables

    $25 
  • Captain Wahoo's Catch of the Day* (Market Price)
    Ask your server for today's catch

     
  • Desserts

  • Flan
    Classic Caramel Flan

    $10 
  • Olivia's Bananas Foster
    Warm Banana Bread, Bananas Foster Sauce, and Vanilla Ice Cream

    $9 
  • Chocolate Fudge Brownie
    with Chocolate Ganache, Dehydrated Strawberries, Mixed Berries, and a Berry Sauce

    $9 
  • Key Lime Pie
    Traditional Key Lime Pie

    $9 
  • Kids' Appetizers (à la carte)

  • Garden Salad
    $3.25 
  • Grapes
    $3.25 
  • Celery and Carrot Sticks
    $3.25 
  • Apple Slices
    $3.25 
  • Kids' Create-Your-Own Entrées (choose one)

  • Grilled Chicken
    Served with choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small DASANI® Bottled Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice

    $11.5 
  • Buttermilk-fried Chicken Strips
    Served with choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small DASANI® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice

    $11.5 
  • Elbow Pasta
    Served with Marinara Sauce and choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small DASANI® Bottled Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice

    $11.5 
  • Seasonal Grilled Fish with Pineapple Salsa
    Served with choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small DASANI® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice

    $13 
  • Kids' Create-Your-Own Selections (choose two)

  • Green Beans
     
  • Brown Rice
     
  • Fruit Cup
     
  • Yogurt Parfait
    with Strawberries

     
  • Non-Alcoholic Beverages

  • Assorted Fountain Beverages
    Coca-Cola®, Diet Coke®, Coca-Cola® Zero Sugar, Sprite®, Barq's® Root Beer, Pibb® Xtra, or Minute Maid® Zero Sugar Lemonade

    $4.79 
  • Freshly Brewed Joffrey's Coffee™
    Regular or Decaf

    $3.99 
  • French Press Pot - Peru Alto Mayo Protected Forest Coffee Roasted by Joffrey's Coffee™ (Serves Two)
    Disney supports Conservation International's Alto Mayo Protected Forest project in Peru, which promotes sustainable coffee growing and economic growth

    $9.25 
  • Non-Alcoholic Mocktails

  • Pink London Spritzer
    Lyre’s Pink London Spirit, Grapefruit Soda, Pomegranate-Green Tea, Lime, and Mint

    $12 
  • Agave Garden
    Lyre’s Agave Reserva Spirit, Cold-pressed Lime Juice, Passionfruit-Papaya-Green Tea, and Cucumber

    $12 
  • Cocktails

  • Blood Orange Margarita
    Lunazul Añejo Tequila, Cointreau Liqueur, Lime Juice, and Blood Orange Sour

    $16 
  • Spicy Poblano Margarita
    Patrón Silver Tequila, Ancho Reyes Verde Liqueur, Lime Juice, and Pure Cane Sugar

    $17 
  • Paloma
    Corazon Blanco Tequila with juices of Ruby Red Grapefruit and Lime topped with Soda Water

    $16 
  • Rum Swizzle
    Mount Gay Eclipse Rum with Tropical Juices and flavors of Guava and Mango

    $15 
  • Raspberry Mojito
    Bacardi Raspberry Rum, Mount Gay Eclipse Rum, Lime Juice, Mint, and Raspberry Purée topped with Soda Water

    $15 
  • Bacardí Mojito
    Bacardí Superior Rum, Lime Juice, Pure Cane Sugar, and Mint topped with Soda Water

    $15 
  • Antioxidant Lemonade
    Van Gogh Açaí-Blueberry Vodka, Odwalla® Lemonade, and Pomegranate Juice topped with Sprite®

    $14.5 
  • Walk the Plank
    Old Forester Bourbon, Orange Juice, Orgeat (Almond), and Lemon Juice garnished with Luxardo Gourmet Maraschino Cherries

    $17 
  • Smoked Turkey
    Wild Turkey 101 Bourbon, Red Stag Black Cherry Bourbon, Grenadine, and Odwalla® Lemonade with a hint of Hickory Smoke, garnished with Luxardo Gourmet Maraschino Cherries

    $17 
  • Whiskey Breeze
    Old Forester Bourbon, Cointreau, and Lime Juice with flavors of Guava and Mango

    $16 
  • Indigo Hibiscus
    Empress 1908 Gin, Bols Blue Curaçao Liqueur, Minute Maid® Premium Lemonade, Orgeat (Almond), Lemon, and Hibiscus Grenadine

    $16 
  • Kentucky Mule
    Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon, Lime Juice, and Pure Cane Sugar topped with Fever Tree Ginger Beer

    $17 
  • Bahama Mama
    Parrot Bay Coconut Rum, Plantation Original Dark Rum, Bols Crème de Banana, and Tropical Juices

    $15 
  • Piña CoLava
    Bacardi Raspberry Rum blended with flavors of Coconut, Pineapple, and Raspberry Purée

    $16 
  • Cold Brew Martini
    SelvraRey Chocolate Rum, Tia Maria Liqueur, and Joffrey's Coffee™ Cold Brew

    $16 
  • Captain’s Mai Tai
    Captain Morgan Original Spiced Rum, Bols Amaretto, and Tropical Juices topped with a float of Myer’s Original Dark Rum

    $15 
  • Sparkling Hibiscus
    Helix7 Vodka, Sorel Liqueur, Lemon, Honey, and Grapefruit Soda

    $17 
  • Chocolate Martini
    Mozart Chocolate Liquor, Stoli Vanil Vodka, Bols White Crème de Cacao, and Frangelico

    $16 
  • Red Sangria
    Opici Family Red Sangria is made in La Mancha, Spain from Tempranillo grapes and has flavors of raspberry, apple, and blackberry with succulent aromas of natural Valencia oranges and cinnamon

    $13 
  • White Sangria
    Opici Family White Sangria is made in La Mancha, Spain from Airén grapes and has flavors of banana, pineapple, and grapefruit with a hint of ginger

    $13 
  • Sunset Margarita
    Teremana Blanco Tequila, Grand Marnier Liqueur, Smoked Chili Bitters, Lime, Agave

    $17 
  • Piña Colada
    SelvaRey Coconut Rum, Pineapple, Agave, Orange Bitters served over ice

    $17 
  • Specialty Cocktails

  • Slappy Joe's Bourbon Berry Lemonade
    Woodford Reserve Bourbon, Bols Blackberry Brandy, and Lemonade with a splash of Soda Water

    $16 
  • Turtle Krawl
    Siesta Key White Rum, Parrot Bay Coconut Rum, and Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum with Grenadine, Pineapple, Orange, and Key Lime Juices

    $15 
  • Key West Freeze
    WÓDKA Vodka and Bols Melon Liqueur blended with flavors of Coconut, Pineapple, and Strawberry

    $15 
  • Rum Runner
    Plantation Original Dark Rum, Bols Crème de Banana, Bols Blackberry Brandy, Orange, and Pineapple Juices with a float of Goslings 151 Rum

    $16 
  • Captain’s Mai Tai
    Captain Morgan Original Spiced Rum, Bols Amaretto, and Tropical Juices topped with a float of Myer’s Original Dark Rum

    $15 
  • Pineapple Mule
    Uncle Nearest 1884 Small Batch Whiskey, Hella Cocktail Co. Ginger Bitters, Pineapple Juice, Ginger Beer, and Mint

    $17 
  • Opici Family White Sangria
    Opici Family White Sangria is made in La Mancha, Spain from Airen Grapes and has flavors of Banana, Pineapple, and Grapefruit with a hint of Ginger

    $13 
  • Opici Family Red Sangria
    Opici Family Red Sangria made in La Mancha, Spain from Tempranillo Grapes and has flavors of Raspberry, Apple, and Blackberry with succulent aromas of natural Valencia Oranges and Cinnamon

    $13 
  • Beverages with Alcohol

  • LiveWire Crystal Shiso Mojito
    Casa Magdalena Rum, Coconut, Shiso, and Lime

    $12.5 
  • High Noon Sun Sips Vodka & Soda Pineapple
    Vodka and Soda with flavors of Pineapple

    $11.75 
  • RAMONA Dry Ruby Grapefruit Wine Spritz
    $11 
  • Beer, Hard Cider, Hard Seltzer | Bottle, Can, or Draft - $7.50 - $12.75

  • Bud Light – St. Louis, MO
     
  • Corona Extra – Mexico
     
  • Stella Artois – Belgium
     
  • Yuengling Traditional Lager – Pottsville, PA
     
  • Blue Moon Belgian White – Golden, CO
     
  • Cigar City Jai Alai IPA – Tampa,FL
     
  • Samuel Adams Seasonal – Boston, MA
    Spring - Cold Snap | Summer - Summer Ale | Fall - OctoberFest | Winter - Winter Lager

     
  • Angry Orchard Crisp Apple Hard Cider - Cincinnati, OH
     
  • Wines

  • Meiomi Rosé, California
    Jammy strawberry, cherry, delicate floral notes with lifted tropical flavors.

    $53 
  • Domaine Ste. Michelle Brut, Columbia Valley
    Delicate aromas of green apple, bright citrus notes with a persistent bubble and balanced acidity.

    $49 
  • Coppa Moncalvina Moscato D'Asti, Piedmont
    Fresh and aromatically balanced with floral notes along with peach and pear overtones.

    $53 
  • Torre di Luna Pinot Grigio, Delle Venezie, Italy
    Crisp and refreshing with zesty citrus, pear, and floral characteristics.

    $42 
  • Dr. Loosen, Dr. L Riesling, Mosel
    Lightly sweet, green apple and citrus flavors elegantly laced with racy acidity and minerality from steep slate slopes.

    $56 
  • Kim Crawford Sauvignon Blanc, Marlborough
    Crisp, bright notes of lime, gooseberry, and grapefruit lift the palate to a refreshing, clean finish.

    $53 
  • Sonoma-Cutrer Chardonnay, Russian River Ranches
    Flavors of apple, pear, and lemon zest highlighted with notes of toasted almonds and barrel spice.

    $67 
  • MacMurray Estate Vineyards Pinot Noir, Russian River Valley
    Raspberry and cherry cola aromas and flavors are balanced in a silky and long, elegant finish.

    $70 
  • Francis Ford Coppola Diamond Collection Merlot, California
    flavors of dark juicy plums, crushed blackberry, eucalyptus, and a hint of warm spice.

    $53 
  • Don Miguel Gascón Malbec, Mendoza
    Dark black plum and blackberry flavors with fruit-forward intensity, smooth and round finish.

    $53 
  • Simi Cabernet Sauvignon, Alexander Valley
    Richly extracted blackcurrant and dark cherry flavors extend to a long, polished finish.

    $75 
  • Allergy-Friendly

  • Menu items may be modified versions of standard menu items. Recipes and ingredients are subject to change without notice. Please speak with a Cast Member regarding your Allergy-Friendly request upon ordering.
     
  • Allergy-Friendly Appetizers

  • Guests must speak to a Cast Member about their allergy-friendly request
     
  • Crab Cake
    Pan-seared and served with Jalapeño Aïoli, Grilled Pineapple Salsa, and Chayote Slaw (For Fish, Milk, and Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

    $15 
  • Shrimp Cocktail
    Jumbo Shrimp, Key West Cocktail Sauce, Tropical Slaw, and Citrus (For Gluten/Wheat, Fish, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, and Sesame Allergies)

    $16 
  • Beer-braised Mussels
    Local Florida Ale, Jalapeño, and Grilled Crostini (For Fish, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

    $18 
  • Savory Hushpuppies
    Served with Key Lime Mustard (For Fish, Peanut/Tree Nut, and Sesame Allergies)

    $12 
  • Seasonal Market Salad
    Mixed Greens, Quinoa, Avocado, Edamame, Orange, and Key Lime Vinaigrette (For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut, and Sesame Allergies)

    $12 
  • Caesar Salad
    Chopped Romaine tossed with Parmesan, House-made Croutons, and Caesar Dressing (For Shellfish, Peanut/Tree Nut, and Sesame Allergies)

    $11 
  • Caesar Salad with Chicken
    Chopped Romaine tossed with Parmesan, House-made Croutons, and Caesar Dressing (For Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Shellfish Allergies)

    $15 
  • Allergy-Friendly Entrées

  • Guests must speak to a Cast Member about their allergy-friendly request
     
  • Slow-cooked Prime Rib*
    Roasted Garlic Mashed Potatoes and Broccolini (For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

    $36 
  • Mojo-brined Pork
    Butter-poached Potatoes, Savory Purée, and Mustard Gastrique (For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

    $29 
  • Mahi Mahi*
    Mahi Mahi with Fingerling Potatoes, Corn Succotash, Chorizo, Citrus Butter, and Corn Silk (For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Shellfish Allergies)

    $30 
  • Shrimp Scampi
    Jumbo Shrimp, Linguine, Tomato, Scallions, and Citrus Butter Sauce (For Egg, Fish, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

    $29 
  • Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken
    Mashed Potatoes, Southern Gravy, Biscuit, and Seasonal Vegetables (For Egg, Fish, Peanut/Tree Nut, and Sesame Allergies)

    $25 
  • Signature Bacon Cheeseburger*
    Cheddar, Crispy Onions, Avocado, and Bacon Jam with House-made Key West Ketchup and Aïoli (For Fish/Shellfish, Peanut/Tree Nut, and Sesame Allergies)

    $24 
  • West Indian Tofu and Coconut Curry
    Mango-Coconut Curry, Crisp Vegetables, Jasmine Rice, and Cilantro (For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut, and Sesame Allergies)

    $23 
  • Allergy-Friendly Desserts

  • Guests must speak to a Cast Member about their allergy-friendly request
     
  • Mixed Berries
    (For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, and Soy Allergies)

    $5.5 
  • Coconut Panna Cotta
    Mango Compote, Crispy Lime Meringue, and Toasted Coconut (For Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Gluten/Wheat, Milk, Peanut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

    $9 
  • Key Lime Pie
    Traditional Key Lime Pie (For Fish/Shellfish, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

    $9 
  • Chocolate Fudge Brownie
    with Chocolate Ganache, Dehydrated Strawberries, Mixed Berries, and a Berry Sauce (For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

    $9 
  • Ice Cream Sundae
    Ice Cream, Chocolate Sauce and Mickey Sprinkles (For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, and Peanut/Tree Nut Allergies)

    $5.25 
  • Allergy-Friendly Kids' Appetizers (à la carte)

  • Guests must speak to a Cast Member about their allergy-friendly request
     
  • Garden Salad with Ranch Dressing
    (For Gluten/Wheat, Fish/Shellfish, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

    $3.25 
  • Grapes
    (For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

    $3.25 
  • Celery and Carrot Sticks
    (For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

    $3.25 
  • Apple Slices
    (For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

    $3.25 
  • Allergy-friendly Kids' Create-Your-Own Entrées (choose one)

  • Guests must speak to a Cast Member about their allergy-friendly request
     
  • Grilled Chicken Breast
    Served with choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small DASANI® Bottled Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice (For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

    $11.5 
  • Buttermilk-fried Chicken Strips
    Served with choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small DASANI® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice (For Fish/Shellfish, Peanut/Tree Nut, and Soy Allergies)

    $11.5 
  • Seasonal Grilled Fish with Pineapple Salsa
    Served with choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small DASANI® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice (For Gluten/Wheat, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, Shellfish, and Soy Allergies)

    $13 
  • Elbow Pasta with Marinara Sauce
    Served with Marinara Sauce and choice of two (2) Selections and choice of Small Lowfat Milk, Small DASANI® Water, or Small Minute Maid® Apple Juice (For Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

    $11.5 
  • Allergy-friendly Kids' Create-Your-Own Selections (choose two)

  • Guests must speak to a Cast Member about their allergy-friendly request
     
  • Green Beans
    (For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

     
  • Brown Rice
    (For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

     
  • Fruit Cup
    (For Gluten/Wheat, Egg, Fish/Shellfish, Milk, Peanut/Tree Nut, Sesame, and Soy Allergies)

     
NOTE: While every effort is made to ensure the accuracy of the menus listed on WDWMAGIC, please be aware that this is an unofficial site, and that menus may change at anytime. Check directly with the restaurant for any updates.